REPORT OF THE CONSULTING GROUP ON CORPORATE IDENTITY
(* = OVERHEAD, to be shown at the time indicated.)
(This presentation was given to the pediatric department of HealthPartners in January 1999.)
Introduction: It is now time for the report from the consultant group on corporate identity.
Thank you for having me here to interface with your... faces. I am Frank Glib,
with the consulting firm, Calvin and Hobbes.(*CALVIN AND HOBBES)
I have been with C&H for 13 years and hold down the position of Vice President
in Charge of Foolish Questions.
In our preliminary study, of your organization, commissioned specifically for
your department, we have identified a number of identity issues (*IDENTITY).
And we are more than happy to talk about them (as long as we keep getting paid
by the hour.) Remember, we are not image MAKERS or spin doctors.
What you are is what you are and we think that's either OK or up to you to
define. (*SPIN [DOWN]) But, fundamentally, we believe that if you are spinning,
you need to make that known to the public in the most positive sense (*SPIN
[UP]). Basically, if you can get the world to spin the same way, they will
appreciate you. [LIGHTS OUT]
A little about us. We are an old firm, but have stayed contemporary. We
actually created and pioneered the identity field.
One of our founder's first clients was a CEO with an identity association of
ruthlessness and bottom-line mentality. He had amassed a large empire and was
really the main force to be reckoned with in his market for over 40 years. His
long-term employees basically worshipped him.
Yet the general perception tended to focus on his more strikingly, uh, pragmatic
business practices, such as eliminating competition by imprisoning and...
enucleating conquered CEO's... and executing their families. Now, you may be
taken aback by this, but it was common at the time and he simply perfected the
technique.
Still, we successfully steered the public away from this potentially negative
perception towards an appreciation of the architectural beauty and
environmental sensitivity of the firm's home office. And today, when you think
of Nebuchadnezzar, you probably think immediately of the Hanging Gardens of
Babylon, and not hanging enemies.
I can show you a prototype of his corporate logo (*HEALTHPARTNERS LOGO). We
feel it is a masterful piece of work, symbolically reducing the four sided
massive wall system of the city, with its 60 mile perimeter and multiple
terraces, to a simple figure that conveys life and growth.
Tragically, we did NOT have the privilege of making a successful final
presentation. In this case, Mr. N. actually terminated the contract... and our
representative, in what must be called an unfortunate example of inadequate
market research and poor timing, ended up in a very hot furnace. [LIGHTS OUT]
Now, of course, your situation is VERY different and we do not think there is as
much to do or as far to go in effectively presenting your organization to the
public. You may have a little more trouble internally but we feel you are also
making a good start there.
The Department of Corporate Communications is a good example. (*A BLIND HORSE)
We liked their Division of Euphemisms (*SEES JUST AS WELL) and the grasp they
showed of the kind of approach we are talking about (*AT EITHER END).
For example: (*BYE-BYE) during the recent layoffs, the pink slips said it all
with the phrase, "Group Health is a great place to work, but you don't work
here anymore."
We recommend that you give this exemplary department a chance to study the
present perceptions of the "IX-NAY Guidelines." (*IX-NAY) It is our initial
finding that there is no perception at all... and that this may be best.
May I interject that we all need to be aware of the latest trends. And as of
this morning, Mr. and Ms. are on the way out as terms of address and reference
in favor of the gender neutral, "M." (*M) [LIGHTS OUT]
For those of you involved in the territorially contested U of M / Fairview newborn
intensive care unit, it should be good news that we have been able to negotiate
a cease fire and arrange for a UN peace keeping force. Partitioning and
self-rule are just around the corner. This was all arranged at a secret
conference in Paris by unnamed high ranking officials. Because of the sensitive
nature of the matter, I am sure you will understand that no overheads are
available. I hope you are still able to follow me. Should I speak more slowly?
(*L-D-R-P) Consumer focus groups on the new L-D-R-P
(Labor/Delivery/Recovery/Post Partum) rooms at "The Birthplace" show high
levels of acceptance . In fact, there is a strong demand for enlargement of
the concept. With the preterm labor program, this can easily become P-L-D-R-P
(Pregnancy/Labor/Delivery/Recovery/PostPartum.) And, of course, incorporating
the infertility service, it becomes C-P-L-D-R-P
(Conception/Pregnancy/Labor/Delivery/Recovery/Post Partum). Unused rooms could
be rented on a short term basis as motel rooms. (*C)
Our study, however, indicates the highest interest in a creative pioneering move
into an entirely new market. (*C-P-L-D-R-P-DC-PS-CP) With concern about the
hazards of Daycare and the steadily plummeting quality of public education, we
recommend the institution of C-P-L-D-R-P-DC-PS-CP. This would incorporate
consumer desires and put your organization in the forefront of the
technological revolution as the only major player in the market for
Conception/Pregnancy/Labor/Delivery/Recovery/Post Partum/Day
Care/Pre-School/College Prep.
On the other hand and at the other end of the ideological spectrum, (*MILLIONS
BIRTHED) we do not discourage the continued development of the "Drive Through
Delivery Service." In fact, there may be room for a joint venture here in
developing an integrated healthcare system (*VAN PEOPLE) for the growing
population of de facto homeless "Van People." [LIGHTS OUT]
Internally, some work needs to be done in the area of the fierce
interdepartmental rivalry for bigger slices of the pie. We have tentatively
identified what appears to be the primary source of your difficulty.
Pediatricians are basically perceived as "Baby Doctors" (*CUTE) and thus small,
weak and easily deceived.
We feel you have taken a big step in the right direction by becoming "Adolescent
Doctors," (*MOODY) thus interjecting a sense of unpredictability and danger into
the equation.
(*POWERFUL) We may come up with a more detailed set of recommendations including
guidelines on the throwing of surgical instruments across the room, or how to
effectively threaten to require routine colonoscopies on upper management. Which
actually makes some sense on a theoretical basis, since it is well known that
they need to be... uh, um." (*PERFECT _____)
Whether or not to select a Department Chairman who is incapable of smiling
(*GROUCHY) becomes a thorny issue. You would probably have to look outside of
your specialty to find the proper personality, unless you limited your search to
the subgroups of Pediatric Pulmonologists, or Neonatologists over the age of
50.
There are a number of unemployed despots around the world who might serve you
well. Let me add that we are completely capable of finding Jimmy Hoffa if you
were really serious about this matter. (*COST/BENEFIT) But the more directive
types of leaders do not come cheap and generally frown on the sort of free
discussion that you, as a Department, seem to constantly require.
Which brings us to another general comment. It has been noted that doctors who
do procedures are paid more than those who talk. (*USE YOUR STRENGTHS) It we
successfully reversed that trend for you, to the extent of physicians being
paid by the word, your specialty would become the new rich.
(*REDISTRIBUTION) Orthopedists would become beggars and internists would have to
say "take these pills" for each prescription. Psychiatrists would tend to
become directive and surgeons would tell their jokes to the patients instead of
the scrub nurses.
(*MORE TO COME) We are optimistic about the future and about your ability to
survive well enough to ask us back in a few years to study the unforeseen
developments (that we actually know about but won't disclose at present rates of
compensation.)
On the horizon, however, is the impact of diversity support groups on the
organization's functional requirements. Although it is not yet a fully
organized or completely defined segment of the workforce, we have tried to
comply with the demands of the "Humor Challenged" Task Force, while
simultaneously avoiding unnecessarily alienating the Orthosociety Helping
Prevent Puns and Other Offenses. (*OH-PPOO)
Therefore, let me close with this. (*PLEASE LAUGH)
Are there any questions?
Questioner: Mr. Glib are you wearing both suspenders and a belt?
I'm glad you asked that question. Next Question?
Questioner: But aren't your suspenders attached to your belt?
Thank you very much and goodbye.
All these dramas may be used and shared freely. If you do use them, I would be interested in knowing about it and hearing comments.
The URL for this document is
|